IAM magazine
2014 IP Management Services
IAM magazine RSS feed IAM magazine on Twitter IAM magazine on Linked-in
Intellectual Asset Management
Subscriber login
Authors   Archive   Sectors  

For the patent-hungry, Rockstar offers the perfect Christmas gift

If you know someone looking for a potentially lucrative patent for Christmas, then you should consider dipping into the recently published Rockstar winter catalogue to see if there is anything in there which might tickle their fancy. Rockstar Winter 2012 Sales Prospects has been sent out to a range of prospective buyers, one of whom has kindly forwarded it to me. According to the executive summary:

Rockstar  periodically  identifies  certain  assets  in  our  portfolio  that  may  be  more  valuable  to other  parties.  The  assets  listed  herein  are  a  small  sample  of  the  assets  under  Rockstar’s management  that  the  company  feels  may  be  of  interest  to  those  parties  who  are  looking  to acquire patents.

They cover the following technologies:

• Social Networking –Message Sharing Privacy by Grouping

• Call Centers – Distributed Internet Call Center Architecture

• Data Networking – Network Address and Port Translation

• Digital Rights Management – Timed Availability of Secured Content

• Digital Signal Processors – Multicore DSP Architecture

• Optical Networking – Generic Framing Procedure for Data Traffic over Optical

• Broadband Services – Individualized Service Policies

This is not the first time Rockstar has put patents in the former Nortel portfolio it manages up for sale, but at first sight it does seem a slightly strange thing to do. After all, if there is value in a patent, you’d have thought that an NPE would look to maximise it through licensing deals rather than a straight sale. If you play your cards right, you should be able to make more money from multiple transactions rather than a straight divestment. And given that many on the Rockstar team used to work in the Nortel IP group, it’s not as if they do not know the rights it manages inside out. Of course, Rockstar is not your typical NPE, given that its major shareholders are five operating companies: Apple, Microsoft, Ericsson, RIM and Sony.  So maybe that has something to do with it.

Of course, a sale can be done under any kind of terms the parties decide upon. So, for example, if some of these patents ended up in the hands of other NPEs, a negotiated percentage of any resulting revenues raised from monetisation programmes could end up in Rockstar’s coffers, while also putting a helpful gap between Rockstar's owners and assertions that may be required to get licensing deals done. That’s a model which Intellectual Ventures has used in the past. It makes you wonder whether Rockstar is still in the market for patents too.

Joff Wild
IAM Magazine
27 November 2012

Forward to a colleague


Recent posts


IP management, Licensing, Patents, IP business


RE: For the patent-hungry, Rockstar offers the perfect Christmas gift

Interesting information but ...

A very simple analysis of this Winter Sale discloses that more than a couple of the patents contained therein appear to build upon technology developed by Check Point Software of Israel.

That being said, these Rockstar offerings are reminiscent of the ill-fated Kodak Sale, in that the offering document states that they are anything but unencumbered, like selling the leftovers from Christmas dinner. Rockstar will only disclose existing licensees under NDA which makes it impossible to get a firm handle on this.

Likely that the cabal that comprises the founders of Rockstar (Apple, Microsoft, Research In Motion, Sony, and Ericsson, et al) undoubtedly have defense and hold harmless agreements that would bind to the acquirer and impair value.

And these patents may in fact be subject to material coverage of other Rockstar patents that pre-date those offered in this sale. Hard to see the value, except perhaps to a potential bidder like NOMADIX or Checkpoint.

John Stec, Byte Law on 28 Nov 2012 @ 15:38

RE: For the patent-hungry, Rockstar offers the perfect Christmas gift

Rockstar's offerings are probably more in the way of "stocking stuffers" than glitzy presents.

After all, Rockstar has already sold the following patents/applications to friends & family:

- 24 patents/applications to Rockstar Consortium US LP;

- 30 patents/applications to Microsoft;

- 238 patents/applications to 2256355 Ontario Limited (a RIM subsidiary that has subsequently sold 233 of them to RIM); and

- 1,106 patents/applications to Apple, Inc.

Of course, the thoughtful shopper knows that he/she just needs to get past Rule 11 in order to reach the bargaining table with the reluctant licensee, and some of these offerings might do the trick.

For the above assignments, the folks at Apple decided to record each assignment individually. That's nearly $45,000 in government fees. The 1,106 patent/application assignment could have been recorded for less than $50 if all the patents/applications had been recorded at once. Maybe Apple throught they were being stealthy this way.

Thomas Ewing, Avancept LLC on 29 Nov 2012 @ 13:18

Write a comment

Please log on or register to leave a comment.


Register for more free content

  • Read more IAM blogs and articles
  • Receive the editor's weekly review by email
Register now  
Issue 0
Push page down